EnjoyingTheSun wrote: ↑Fri 16 Jul 2021 7:34 am
Didn’t watch the whole video because I prefer my comedy funny.
Listen to yourself ETS. "I have not watched the whole video but here is what I think about the video". Variants of such "I have not read or listened to what you have said but here is what I think about what you have said'. "I have not read the report on racism in the UK but here is what I think about the report on racism in the UK".
EnjoyingTheSun wrote: ↑Fri 16 Jul 2021 7:34 am
Never heard of this guy but no doubt he is a regular on those panel shows on Channel 4 so earns a living?
That is exactly your problem mate as far as I am concerned. You have no doubt. That is why you do not have to watch the video to be able to share your views on it, listen to what anyone has said to be able to share your views on it etc etc. You know already without any of that tedious stuff. Have always known. No need to progress or refine or change in any way. Your lack of doubt scares me.
EnjoyingTheSun wrote: ↑Fri 16 Jul 2021 7:34 am
What always DOES amuse me with these comedians is the reaction of the audience. No uncontrollable belly laughs ever. Just forced polite laughter, bit of nodding as you say to your partner and friend “did you see what he did there, sooooo clever.” As they force a smile.
Where in the course of a joke would you expect the most 'audience reaction' if there was to be one ? At the end, after the punchline perhaps ? But you did not watch the whole video did you ? Now I know you are a busy man and have much on your plate scouring the internet for proof that the racial attacks on the England players that missed penalties was not 'that bad really' and the like. Important work no doubt. So I have made it easy for you. Unfortunately given the way the system works I can not embed the video in this post so that it starts at the punch line for you. I can only provide a link that does that. I realise that even clicking this may be too much effort for you given how much you have on your plate but here goes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8zgZ2JtVfm4&t=161s
This then is the audience reaction you characterise as being " Just forced polite laughter, bit of nodding as you say to your partner and friend “did you see what he did there, sooooo clever.” As they force a smile" having admitted you
did not even watch the video to the end. Funny because I do not see, by actually looking what you managed to see without even having to look at all.
EnjoyingTheSun wrote: ↑Fri 16 Jul 2021 7:34 am
Still I guess that why they have to be supported by our licence fees because they sure won’t ever going to making a living selling DVDs of their shows.
In my experience guesses made in wilful ignorance are generally less likely to reflect any sort of actual reality than those made after some attempt to look first at actual reality. I do get it. It does not matter to you what the reality in this case may or may not be. It is literally irrelevant to you. What matters is you making some generalised point regardless of if it does or does not apply in this case. I get it and it is ok. Can you get that just because this is what you chose to do that does not mean it is what everyone else does or should chose to do ?
EnjoyingTheSun wrote: ↑Fri 16 Jul 2021 7:34 am
So to be clear only white people can be racist now because of their history or material success in the past and their position and material success now?
That’s pretty much the theory isn’t it?
That’s why we couldn’t even say that black people can be racist and often are. African v Caribbean. Within the Caribbean, Big Island v Small Island. Black v South Asian. Sikh v Muslim.
All of the above is irrelevant and not real racism because Britain colonised the world hundreds of years ago and white people generally might be better off than black people? That is white privilege?
I believe that seeking to end racism is all about personal choices. About making the choice to try and understand racism better. Is about progressing and continually refining and improving my understanding of it , whilst knowing there is no end 'answer'. I have always struggled to some degree or other with the idea of what is the difference between racism and prejudice. The difference between racism and prejudice based on race. This guy, this joke, to some degree and in some way has aided me in that journey of constantly seeking to refine my understanding of racism. That is why I posted the video. Helped me, might help others.
To be abused racially as say a white person in the UK by a black person in the UK, which can and does happen, is not the same as being racially abused as a black person by a white one. There are levels and degrees of commonality between these two and I do not and have never said otherwise. There are also levels and degrees of difference as well. I also do not deny this. Material differences. Differences I want to understand better because I chose to want to as a means to playing my part in ending racism.
To be racially abused as a white person in the UK , that is (still) predominately white and within a global culture that is predominated white and where your statistical outcomes because of your race are not negatively affected simply because you are white is not the same as being racially abused by a white person or another black person. Not in generic terms and certainly not in the impact it has on a given individual. Similarities ? Yes at some levels in some ways and to some degrees. Differences. Yes at some levels in some ways and to some degree.
EnjoyingTheSun wrote: ↑Fri 16 Jul 2021 7:34 am
During Britain’s colonial days 99% of the white people in a Britain barely had enough to eat and were exploited. This is despite their fellow white British people actually owning the empire. Yes there was slavery. There was also indentured servitude. Far more people arrived in America in indentured servitude than as slaves. Even Howard Zinn as left wing a historian you’ll ever find admits indentured servants were pretty much slaves.
They were different days time to move on.
False equivalence and one wrong negates another wrong rhetorical techniques. Did many 10's of millions of ordinary people globally come out on to the streets to make a stand against indentured servitude ?
EnjoyingTheSun wrote: ↑Fri 16 Jul 2021 7:34 am
As for the whole nonsense that a black person couldn’t racially abuse a white person because of the past and current status that is as logical as saying that Mad Frankie Fraser at 5’1 couldn’t bully a 6 feet plus guy because of the obvious disparity in height.
Straw man rhetorical technique. No one is saying a black person can not racially abuse a white one. Not this comedian. Not me. Not anyone that I can see. What is being said is that when that happens there are differences compared with when a white person does it to a black one.
That today western european cultural, military and economic power is as strong as it is, is inextricably linked to the reality and fact that in preceding centuries white western europeans did go around the world colonising other non white , non European races and cultures. What is more we did so using notions and justifications of the white man's superiority over these lesser people and cultures. On a scale never seen before. That whilst we did this we also did bad things to white people as well does not change this reality. You can chose to believe that the UK's status today as one of only five permanent members of the UN security council, that our position nationally in terms of relative wealth of nations, that our global power today soft and hard , that our status as a nuclear power are all entirely and totally unconnected in any way or to any degree with the fact that in the 17,18 and first half of the 19th centuries we waged war on and subjugated other people and other races and their lands and their resources. Believe that if we had not waged such race wars in those centauries we still today have reached the place we are today nationally in terms of wealth and power. That is your prerogative to believe that. Your choice. It is not my choice.
This historical context, this historical reality does mean that to be racially abused as a black person in the UK or US by a white person is not the same as to be so abused as a white person by a black one.
EnjoyingTheSun wrote: ↑Fri 16 Jul 2021 7:34 am
As for white privilege that pre-supposes that say in a job interview the person hiring is a bigot and that colour would make any difference? Recent events have shown that there still are some bigots but they are pretty thin in the ground.
Another fundamental failure of comprehension to me. Another case of getting it ass about tit. The whole notion of white privilege is that statistical negative outcomes based on race in things like employment can and do continue to persist
without the people hiring having to be bigots. That is the whole point. The one you miss entirely. The one you get ass about tit. Those of us that want to play our part in ending racism, by understanding it better want to understand why this is so.
EnjoyingTheSun wrote: ↑Fri 16 Jul 2021 7:34 am
Being tall is a privilege having big breasts is a privilege and on and on.
The modern world today is not one inextricably linked to and a result of preceding centauries of enslavement and subjugation of short people by tall people. On the enslavement and subjugation of the small breasted by the big breasted. It is the result of a preceding history of systematic enslavement and subjugation of black people by white people.
EnjoyingTheSun wrote: ↑Fri 16 Jul 2021 7:34 am
Here’s the thing if white do- gooders and black race hustlers spend all their time telling black kids they are bound to fail because of structural racism and that it isn’t their fault because of slavery hundreds of years ago then they probably will fail.
Just more straw man arguments imo. People, whatever derisory term you use for them, do not go around telling black kids they are bound to fail. Just does not happen. What many parents of black and mixed race children in places like the UK and US do tell their kids are things like 'be careful around the police, do not antagonise them, do not give them an excuse' and 'you will encounter racism' and 'you will have to work harder and smarter to reach your goals and objectives than if you are white'. They tell them these things because of their experiences and their reality and experience of being black in such places.
and now I have enough for now. I am not avoiding anything. I am tired and want to talk about (learn about , progress and refine my understanding of) something else.